Blog Layout

Girl Assaulted in Uber Ride, Driver Facing Criminal and Civil Cases

Frank Buck • Jun 18, 2015

A Virginia Beach family has filed a lawsuit against former Uber driver, 39-year-old Isagani Alvaro Morin, for inappropriate sexual contact with a middle school student. The lawsuit also names Uber as a defendant. The 13-year-old girl, who was not named in the lawsuit filed anonymously by her mother, states that she frequently used the Uber app to get rides to and from school over the course of two months in the fall of 2014. Morin would most often be the driver who arrived to drive the girl. Over the course of the ten to twenty rides she took with Morin, the driver made a number of inappropriate comments to the girl, including, “Age doesn’t matter if two people are in a relationship,” and making her pinky swear that she would not get another boyfriend. The girl consistently gave Morin a low rating on the app, but whenever she would use the app to request a ride, she continued to receive Morin as her driver. The incidents culminated in Morin reaching back and rubbing the child’s inner thigh and asking her if her mother was at home. The child then ran crying into the house, and her mother immediately called the police. According to the lawsuit, which is requesting $2 million in damages, the incidents caused the girl to experience severe anxiety and emotional distress.

The assault itself is not in dispute. While the behavior did not rise to the standard for sexual assault under Virginia state law, Morin did plead guilty to the assault earlier this year and received a 6-month prison sentence, which was suspended on the condition of one year of good behavior. The case raises an important question of whether or not Uber is responsible for its drivers’ behavior. The lawsuit claims that Uber did not adequately screen or check the background of Morin prior to allowing him to be a driver, that the company knew or should have known that Morin would exhibit sexually aggressive behavior toward his passengers, and that Uber should have intervened and taken Morin off the roads sooner than it did.

Normally, when an employee who is performing services for his employer commits illegal acts during the course of that employment, the employer can be held financially responsible for those acts. Uber has claimed in the past that it is only a ride arranging app and should not be considered the employer of its drivers for legal purposes. However, in a recent case in California, a court found that Uber is an employer of its drivers and can be held responsible for their conduct. This case may give Virginia courts an opportunity to say that Uber drivers are employees of Uber, and to hold Uber responsible for its wrongful conduct.

If your or a loved one have experienced assault, after you have contacted the police, investigate whether you may also be entitled to compensation for ensuing mental health expenses and pain and suffering. Contact the compassionate Charlottesville personal injury attorneys at Buck, Toscano & Tereskerz, Ltd. for a free consultation on your possible claim.

By David Matine 03 Nov, 2022
When two or more individuals hold title to real estate property together, the type of ownership that is very often used is called “joint tenancy with a right of survivorship.” Under this arrangement, each owner, referred to as a “joint tenant”, possesses an equal share of the property. And when one of the owners... Read More » The post Joint Tenancy Problems in Estate Planning appeared first on Buck, Toscano & Tereskerz, Ltd..
By David Matine 11 Oct, 2022
Virginia residents who own real estate property can use a transfer on death deed (TODD) to automatically transfer property directly to beneficiaries upon the owner’s death. This can be a good estate planning strategy, especially for those whose primary asset is their house and they do not have much other property. With a transfer... Read More » The post Virginia’s Transfer on Death Deed: What You Need to Know appeared first on Buck, Toscano & Tereskerz, Ltd..
By David Matine 03 Oct, 2022
When a couple gets divorced, one of the most complicated issues that will need to be resolved is the division of marital property. This is especially true if the spouses have accumulated significant assets during the time that they were married. One marital asset that is particularly difficult to divide is an annuity. This... Read More » The post Dividing an Annuity in a Virginia Divorce Settlement appeared first on Buck, Toscano & Tereskerz, Ltd..
By David Matine 30 Aug, 2022
The goal of anyone making an estate plan is to make the probate process stress-free for their surviving loved ones as their final wishes are carried out. Usually, estate planning documents, such as a legally valid will, can mitigate the majority of potential challenges and help avoid probate court controversy. However, estate planning fraud... Read More » The post How to Recognize Fraud in Estate Planning appeared first on Buck, Toscano & Tereskerz, Ltd..
By David Matine 05 Aug, 2022
When an heir to an estate plan passes away, it is time to get in touch with an experienced estate planning lawyer to make the necessary changes to your plan.   If you need legal help with any type of estate planning matters in Virginia, contact Buck, Toscano & Terezkerz. We work closely with... Read More » The post Revising Your Estate Plan After The Death Of An Heir appeared first on Buck, Toscano & Tereskerz, Ltd..
By David Matine 05 Aug, 2022
One of the most contentious issues that must be resolved during a divorce is the division of the marital estate. Whenever there is money and property involved, it can trigger emotional responses. One question that often causes these types of feelings is which spouse gets to keep the house that the couple is currently... Read More » The post Navigating a Home Transfer During a Virginia Divorce appeared first on Buck, Toscano & Tereskerz, Ltd..
By David Matine 05 Jul, 2022
Many cohabitating couples choose not to get married these days, and a lot of them have children together. Unmarried couples living with children they have together are not much different from married couples with children. And just like with a lot of marriages, unmarried couples often decide to split up as well, leaving the... Read More » The post Why Unmarried Parents Should Still Work Out Child Custody Arrangements appeared first on Buck, Toscano & Tereskerz, Ltd..
By David Matine 29 Jun, 2022
When individuals prepare their wills, they are often only thinking about their physical property (such as real estate, vehicles, jewelry, etc.) and financial accounts. Digital estate planning is a fairly recent concept, and it is something that is frequently overlooked when people set up their estate plans. Digitized assets can be very valuable in... Read More » The post Digital Estate Planning: Protecting Your Online Assets appeared first on Buck, Toscano & Tereskerz, Ltd..
By David Matine 15 Jun, 2022
If you have recently gone through a divorce, you may be feeling a sense of relief that the process is over, along with a combination of excitement and anxiety about what lies ahead. But before you get too far into your post-divorce life, there is one area that you should address: your estate plan.... Read More » The post Estate Planning After Divorce appeared first on Buck, Toscano & Tereskerz, Ltd..
By David Matine 01 Jun, 2022
When couples are getting divorced and one of the spouses has received a significant inheritance (or they are going to receive one in the near future), they often wonder how this inheritance might impact the divorce settlement. What effect (if any) will an inheritance have on the division of property? How will it impact... Read More » The post How Do Inheritances Impact a Virginia Divorce? appeared first on Buck, Toscano & Tereskerz, Ltd..
More Posts
Share by: